Maintaining a Healthy Starter: The Key to Perfect Sourdough Bread

January 10, 2025

Your sourdough starter is the foundation of all your sourdough baking adventures. It’s a living culture that needs care and attention to thrive. Whether you're a beginner or an experienced baker, understanding how to maintain a healthy starter is essential for baking consistently great bread.

In this guide, you’ll learn:

How to feed your starter on a regular schedule.
How to recognize signs of an active and thriving starter.
How to troubleshoot and fix common starter problems.
How to store your starter when taking a break, like going on vacation.
How to adjust starter usage for different recipes and high-altitude baking.

1. Feeding Your Starter: A Schedule That Works

Why Feeding Your Starter is Important

Your starter is alive, made up of wild yeast and beneficial bacteria. Regular feedings provide it with the nutrients it needs to stay active and healthy.

How Often Should You Feed Your Starter?

Daily: If kept at room temperature, feed once every 12 or 24 hours.
Weekly: If stored in the fridge, feed once a week.

Note: Your starter can be safely stored in the refrigerator for up to 3 weeks. After this, its activity may decrease, requiring extra feedings to revive it.

Step-by-Step Feeding Instructions

Discard: Remove most of the starter, keeping only 20% of its weight.
- Example: If you plan to feed with 100g flour, keep 20g starter (discard the rest).
Feed: Add equal weights of flour and water.
- Example: Add 100g flour and 100g water to the 20g starter.
Mix: Stir until smooth. Cover loosely and let it sit at room temperature.

Pro Tip: To keep your starter at its maximum performance, add 5% whole wheat flour to your feedings. If you can mill the flour yourself, even better, it adds extra nutrients that promote a healthy, active starter.

2. Storing Your Starter in the Fridge for Vacations

How Long Can a Starter Last in the Fridge?

Your starter can be stored in the refrigerator for up to 3 weeks without a problem. The cold temperature slows down yeast activity, allowing the starter to rest.

Steps to Prepare Your Starter for Refrigeration

Feed Before Storing: Feed your starter as usual, ensuring it’s well-fed and active before placing it in the fridge.
Use a Tight Lid: Cover the jar with a tight-fitting lid to prevent drying out.
Label the Jar: Add the date you stored it to keep track of how long it’s been refrigerated.

Reviving Your Starter After Refrigeration

Bring to Room Temperature: Remove the starter from the fridge and let it sit at room temperature for a few hours.
Discard and Feed: Discard most of the starter, keeping 20g, and feed with equal weights of flour and water.
Repeat Feedings: Feed it daily for 2-3 days until it’s bubbly, doubles in size within 4-6 hours, and has a pleasant aroma.

3. Recognizing Signs of a Healthy Starter

A healthy starter will show clear signs of activity. Here’s what to look for:

Key Indicators of an Active Starter

Bubbling and Rising: The starter doubles in size 4-6 hours after feeding.
Fragrant Aroma: Smells tangy, fruity, or mildly yeasty (not sour or unpleasant).
Elastic Texture: When stirred, it has a stretchy, elastic consistency.

When is Your Starter Ready to Bake?

Your starter is ready to use when:

It has doubled in size after a feeding.
It passes the “float test”: A small spoonful floats in water

NOTE: This step is optional. If your started doubles in size - no need to do a float test.

4. Troubleshooting Common Starter Problems

Problem 1: Starter Isn’t Bubbling or Rising

Cause: Starter may be too cold or underfed.
Fix: Move it to a warmer spot (75°F-80°F) and feed it twice a day until active.

Problem 2: Starter Smells Bad

Cause: Overfermentation or contamination.
Fix: Discard most of the starter and feed with fresh flour and water. If the smell persists, restart with a small portion of the starter.

Problem 3: Starter is Watery or Has a Layer of Liquid (“Hooch”)

Cause: Underfeeding or prolonged storage.
Fix: Stir in the liquid or pour it off, then feed the starter as usual. Increase feeding frequency.

Problem 4: Starter Has Mold

Cause: Contaminated or poorly stored starter.
Fix: Discard the starter if mold is present. It’s unsafe to use. Restart with fresh flour and water.

5. FAQ: Quick Starter Questions

How Long Can I Store a Starter Without Feeding?

Room Temperature: Up to 48 hours.
Refrigerated: Up to 3 weeks.

Can I Use Whole Wheat or Rye Flour for Feedings?

Yes! Whole wheat or rye flour can boost activity due to their nutrient content.

What Should I Do if I Miss a Feeding?

Feed as soon as possible. If the starter has been neglected for several days, discard most of it and give it two consecutive feedings.

6. How Much Starter Do You Need for Bread?

The amount of starter you use in a recipe impacts the rise time, flavor, and overall texture of your bread. A typical guideline is to use 20% of the total flour weight in your recipe.

Example Calculation for Starter Use

If your recipe calls for:

1000g total flour, you’ll need:
- 200g starter (1000g x 0.20 = 200g).

Adjustments for High Altitude

At high altitudes (like Albuquerque, 5,000 ft.), you’ll likely need 30-50% less starter to account for faster fermentation caused by lower atmospheric pressure. This adjustment is especially important in the summer when temperatures are higher.

Adjusted Example for High Altitude

For the same 1000g of flour:

30% less starter: 140g starter (200g x 0.70 = 140g).
50% less starter (summer): 100g starter (200g x 0.50 = 100g).

7. Ready to Bake? Master Your Starter with Us!

Hands-on sourdough baking classes in Albuquerque

Maintaining a healthy starter is the first step to sourdough success. If you’re looking to refine your skills, join one of our hands-on sourdough baking classes at Sherwood Coffee 'n' Bread in Albuquerque. Learn how to work with your starter and bake sourdough bread that’s as beautiful as it is delicious.

Looking for the Complete Sourdough Guide?

Your starter is just the beginning of your sourdough journey! For a comprehensive guide on mastering sourdough baking, including step-by-step instructions and tips, check out our main article: Master Sourdough Baking: Step-by-Step Guide and Resources.

Back to blog